All Island Cafe

Reviews

• April D.

  star star star star star 24 May 2026

  Amazing food. I have eaten here for years and was recommended to me by some Jamaican friends. Just try it, you will love the food.

• Shawn S.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 20 May 2026

  Me and my daughter was waiting on our food and from the ceiling a rat  fell down , ran across the table brushed against me and my daughter, I jumped back and fell outta my chair
  
  It was ya and like 8 more customers. Not sure right now if I hurt my back or not, my adrenaline probably saved me from injury
  Needless to say I ask for a refund and the other customers followed
  
  Very disappointed

• Hiro O.

  star star star star star_border 17 May 2026

  3.5 stars no way this place is a 4-5 star TRUST ME! Ive been to Jamaica lived in NY/NJ been to tons of great Jamaican restaurants and this was lit! The real DEAL, authentic Jamaican food spot 110%
  Hands down one of the Best Oxtails ive had in a while!
  Let me break it down... the oxtails seasonly cooked to perfection, and very very tasty and the portions were generously portioned, on top of the authentic rice n peas with one of my favorite side of steamed cabbage. My friend ordered the Fish and the jerk chicken out of this world! When im back im definitely going back!

• Joche' H.

  star star star star star 16 May 2026

  I dined in at All Island Cafe last Saturday for the first time with family. According to my mother in law, it is usually extremely crowded, but last Saturday it was not for Mother's day weekend around lunch time. This rating is based strictly off of the food. Our waitress was good, but they were out of some of the items on the menu, i.e lemonade, macaroni and cheese, beef patties (all patties), and the plantains were not ripe (but she explained this before we ordered them, so I appreciated it). I also did not like that I could not leave a credit tip, since I was paying with my credit card. So make sure to bring cash for your server if you dine in. It took a while for us to be served because there were to-go orders in front of us. But it was DEFINITELY worth the wait. The food was delicious. I ordered brown stew chicken with rice,peas and cabbage for my son. I ordered the large oxtail with rice,peas and cabbage for myself. Both meals came with 2 or 3 plantains, and I added cocoa bread. My hubby ordered jerk chicken. My uncle ordered curry chicken. My mother in law ordered a veggie plate, and my brother in law order the King Fish. The cocoa bread was fresh and warm. The rice was flavorful, creamy, and buttery. My picky 3 year old tore his food up (see the picture). He did not eat all of it but he definitely ate half, with the rest for dinner. My oxtails were amazing!!!!!!!! I got to sample some of the jerk chicken, and it was also great. My brother and law let us taste his King Fish, and let me just say that I am ordering that next time! All Island Cafe is not a fancy restaurant by any definition, but the chef knows what he or she is doing. I highly recommend All Island Cafe. It is the best Jamaican food that I have tried in Atlanta (and Bahamas LOL) hands down! Get it to go if you have to! I'll be back soon :)

• Aaron S.

  star star star star star 10 May 2026

  My fiancé and I found out they had sorrel/hibiscus drink. It's sweetened just right, and it doesn't taste too "gingery" which is great. So when we found out we went back immediately a few days after our 1st visit. Not only was the food delicious but the drink to wash down the food was tasty reminded me of Trini- sorrel my grandma use to make. If you haven't tried that drink you should but just a heads up if it's not something you're use to it's a bit tangy, little tarty, and sweet. The Jamaican version sorrel has a ginger taste to it, sorta tastes like ginger juice. But again this doesn't taste like ginger juice, which is great I'll be back for more Sorrel and more delicious food and be sure to spread the word.